New York City

Reviews New York City Bars

Please Don't Tell, East Village
Please Don't Tell, St Marks Place

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Speakeasy cocktail bar in East Village, New York City

Please Don't Tell

Pick Up the Phone

3.5 of 5

The entrance is a phone booth inside a hot dog shop. You pick up the receiver, announce yourself, and a wall opens. It sounds like a joke from a bad movie. It is the real front door of PDT, and it has been fooling out-of-towners and delighting locals on St Marks Place for years.

Behind the wall sits a small bar of craft cocktails averaging about sixteen dollars, per Time Out, which is a fair price for the effort. The kitchen is the Crif Dogs next door, so you can get hot dogs delivered to your stool, with toppings like kimchi, pastrami and elote. The review warns they are sloppy and not ideal for a first date. That is exactly why they are good.

It is open Sunday to Thursday from five to two and Friday and Saturday from five to three, and walk-ins may be turned away when it is full. Reserve on Resy if you can. Go with one friend, not six. Order a drink, then order a dog, then admit the wall opening was worth it. It is a small room, so the table next to you becomes part of your night. Be nice to them, because they are probably a bartender on a night off and they know exactly what is good.

Order this
A craft cocktail, A hot dog from Crif Dogs, Something with kimchi or pastrami on top
The damage
$$
Go
Early, a weeknight, with a reservation
Find it
113 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003
Website
pdtnyc.com