New York City

Reviews New York City Bars

Superbueno, East Village
Superbueno, First Avenue

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Mexican-American cocktail bar in East Village, New York City

Superbueno

Cantina With Credentials

3.5 of 5

A bar that ranks ninth on North America's 50 Best Bars list for 2026 could be forgiven for acting serious. Superbueno on First Avenue acts like a party instead. It calls itself a cantina, and co-owners Ignacio Jimenez and Greg Boehm have built a room that celebrates Mexican-American culture and stays loud from early afternoon until close.

The drinks keep the humor and add skill. The Vodka y Soda is built on clarified guava with a chili emulsion and triple sec. The Fresca Tonic mixes gin and sotol with a pomegranate fig tonic and a sour apple agua fresca. The low and no alcohol menu is celebrated, with the Chamony Gimlet leading that list. Beer comes with house-made tajin and wormsalt, which is a small detail that tells you how closely somebody is watching.

The crowd is mixed, the volume is up, and the mood is generous. Go early and you get a seat and a conversation. Go late and you get a scene. Either way, order something you have never had and let the bartender talk you into the second one. It is a good-natured room that happens to be very good at its job. It is a great stop before dinner or a fine way to end a night, and it welcomes both ways of using it. Ask for something without alcohol too, because that list deserves its reputation.

Order this
Vodka y Soda with clarified guava, Fresca Tonic, The Chamony Gimlet, alcohol free, House tajin on a beer
The damage
$$$
Go
Early evening, before the crowd
Find it
13 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003