New York City

Reviews New York City Bars

Angel's Share, West Village
Angel's Share, Grove Street

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Japanese-style cocktail bar in West Village, New York City

Angel's Share

The Quiet One Moved

4 of 5

Angel's Share opened in 1993 and taught a lot of American bartenders how to behave. Quiet room, seated guests, careful hands, no fuss. The 50 Best page credits it with paving the way for the cocktail revolution and with influencing PDT and Milk & Honey. Anyone who loves a small, serious bar owes it a thank-you.

The original sat on Stuyvesant Street in the East Village. That space has closed, and the bar now lives at 45 Grove Street in the West Village. The new address hasn't changed the manners. The menu pairs inventive drinks built on mezcal, amaro and shochu with well-balanced classics, and cocktails average about twenty-three dollars. It placed 31st on North America's 50 Best Bars for 2026, up from 43rd the year before.

It opens Tuesday through Saturday, so plan for it. The rules are the point: no shouting, no big groups, no phones out for the photo. Early in the week, a stool and the bartender's choice is the whole plan. The reward is a drink somebody has thought hard about and a room quiet enough to enjoy it. Respect the house rules and the house returns the favor. Most people who leave this room feel like they were in a library with better lighting and stronger drinks.

Order this
A classic cocktail, made with care, Something with mezcal, amaro or shochu, A seat at the bar
The damage
$$$
Go
Weeknight, early, seated, not standing
Find it
45 Grove St, New York, NY 10014