New York City

Reviews New York City Dinner

Torrisi, Nolita
Torrisi, Mulberry Street

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Italian-American, contemporary in Nolita, New York City

Torrisi

Martini Glass Affogato

3.5 of 5

Torrisi lives in the historic Puck Building on Mulberry Street, and the staff look like they have never once been in a hurry. Pressed linens, impeccable dress, a room with an inviting buzz. The Michelin Guide gives it one star and calls it inventive and approachable at once. The Italian-American food is the point, and it is cooked by people who know the red-sauce canon cold.

The menu reimagines familiar dishes with polish: tuna with pickled caponata, penne with sautéed chanterelles in butter sauce, Dover sole done Francese-style. Then dessert is an affogato in an oversized martini glass with vanilla ice cream, chocolate fudge and espresso granita. It is silly and delicious, and the joke only works because the dinner before it was serious.

The Michelin listing shows Monday and Tuesday from 5 PM to 11 PM and Wednesday to Saturday lunch from 11:30 AM to 2 PM, so check the booking page for dinner service. The price band is the highest. Nolita reinvents itself faster than most menus change. A room that carries the old neighborhood style with this much care is worth the table. Save room for the martini glass. It is the kind of dessert that gets the whole table arguing about spoons, and a dinner that ends in an argument about spoons has done its job.

Order this
Tuna with pickled caponata, Penne with sautéed chanterelles in butter sauce, Dover sole Francese-style, The affogato in an oversized martini glass
The damage
$$$$
Go
Check the booking page, since listed hours show Monday and Tuesday dinner and Wednesday to Saturday lunch
Find it
275 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10012