The Four Billion Trees America Lost
In the summer of 1904 a forester named Hermann Merkel walked the grounds of the New York Zoological Garden in the Bronx and stopped at a chestnut tree. The bark had cracked. There were small orange spots in the cracks, and the leaves above them had wilted on the branch. He found the same thing on the next tree, and the one after that.
He was looking at the beginning of one of the largest losses any forest has suffered. How does a whole tree vanish from a continent?
The tree that was everywhere
The American chestnut, Castanea dentata, was once one of the great trees of the eastern United States. In parts of the Appalachian Mountains about one tree in four was a chestnut. It grew tall and straight, and its wood was light, easy to split and slow to rot.
People built their lives from it. Barns and cabins were raised from chestnut logs, fences split from chestnut rails, the dead buried in chestnut caskets. Tanneries stripped the bark for its tannin. In autumn the nuts fell in such numbers that families gathered them by the sack, fed them to their hogs, and sold the rest in town. In 1912 the standing chestnut timber in just three states was valued at 82.5 million dollars.
A fungus from across the sea
In 1905 the mycologist William Murrill isolated the cause, a fungus now called Cryphonectria parasitica. It had almost certainly come in on chestnut trees imported from Japan for planting and breeding. Asian chestnuts had lived beside the fungus for a long time and could carry it without much harm. The American tree had never met it.
The fungus slipped in through cracks in the bark and grew around the trunk, cutting the tree off from its own water and sugar. Spores rode the wind, the rain and the feet of birds. Within a few years it had turned up at sites up and down the East Coast. By 1940 most of the mature American chestnuts had been girdled. Estimates of the dead run from about three and a half billion trees to four billion.
The disease crossed the Atlantic too. It was found near Genoa in 1938 and spread through the chestnut woods of Italy and France. A milder strain of the fungus, weakened by a virus, later helped many European trees recover. America was not so lucky.
What the forest kept
The blight kills a chestnut above ground, not below. Old roots across the Appalachians still send up shoots, which grow for a few years, sometimes long enough to flower, before the fungus finds them and they die back again. A forest is still trying to grow a tree it lost a century ago.
A few pure stands survived far from the old range. The largest, near West Salem in Wisconsin, held about 2,500 trees planted by settlers on 60 acres, until blight reached it in 1987. Breeders have spent decades crossing the American tree with resistant Asian ones, and a handful of hybrid trees have now been planted again at the Bronx Zoo, where the story began.
The nut on the street corner
The roasted chestnuts sold on American street corners at this time of year are now almost all imported, from Italy, Korea and China. The tree that once fed the hills of Virginia and Kentucky is a memory kept in barn beams and old fence rails. In the woods the roots keep sending up their thin green shoots, a forest writing the same letter every spring to someone who no longer answers.
