How to Roast Chestnuts Without an Open Fire
July 1945, Los Angeles, a heat wave. A songwriter named Bob Wells is trying to cool down by thinking about winter. He writes a few lines on a pad: chestnuts roasting, frost in the air, the street-corner vendors of his Boston childhood selling them in paper cones. His friend Mel Torme, nineteen years old, arrives, reads the pad, and sits down at the piano. By most accounts the song is finished in about forty-five minutes. A year later Nat King Cole records The Christmas Song, and every December since, the world has been told to roast its chestnuts on an open fire.
Most of us do not have one. What do you do with a bag of chestnuts and an oven?
Buy the heavy ones
A chestnut is a fresh food, more like a fruit than a nut. It loses water from the day it falls, and a dry one roasts hard and shrivelled. In the shop:
- Pick them up: good chestnuts feel heavy for their size and firm all over.
- Look at the shell: it should be glossy and tight. Skip any with small holes, cracks or mould.
- Shake the bag: a rattle inside a shell means the nut has dried and shrunk away from it.
Keep them in the fridge in a paper bag, and use them within a week or two.
Cut every one
This is the rule that matters. A chestnut is full of water. In the heat of the oven that water turns to steam, and a sealed shell holds it in until it bursts, sometimes loudly enough to make you jump, sometimes hard enough to scatter hot shell across the oven.
Lay each nut flat side down on a board and cut a cross, or a single long slash, through the shell on the rounded side. Use a short, sharp knife and cut through the shell but not deep into the nut. The cut lets the steam out. It also gives you a corner to peel from later.
A few minutes in a bowl of warm water before roasting helps the shell soften and the inside steam.
Roast hot and fast
- Heat the oven to 220 C (425 F).
- Spread the chestnuts in one layer on a tray, cut side up.
- Roast for 20 to 30 minutes, until the cuts have curled open and the nut inside looks golden. Shake the tray once halfway.
Small chestnuts cook faster than large ones, so test one early. It should be soft and floury all the way through, with no waxy centre.
Wrap them, then peel
Tip the hot chestnuts into a clean kitchen towel, fold it over and leave them for ten to fifteen minutes. The steam trapped inside loosens both the shell and the thin, bitter brown skin underneath. Peel them while they are still warm. Cold chestnuts grip their skins, and the skin is the part nobody wants.
What to do with them
- Eat them as they are, with a little salt and a glass of something red.
- Toss them into a pan with Brussels sprouts, butter and bacon.
- Chop them into stuffing, and you have a rehearsal for next week’s Thanksgiving.
- Freeze the extras: scored raw chestnuts keep in the freezer for months and can go straight into the oven.
The window in July
Somewhere in a hot room in 1945, a man wrote down a winter he could not feel, from a memory of cold streets and paper cones. The chestnuts in your oven are the real thing his song was made from. Open the oven door, let the smell into the kitchen, and pass the towel full of them across the table.
