Winnipeg

Reviews Winnipeg Dinner

Café Carlo, Corydon
Café Carlo, Winnipeg

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Italian neighborhood restaurant in Corydon, Winnipeg

Café Carlo

Pasta Since 1989

3.5 of 5

Restaurants usually die young. Café Carlo has been feeding Winnipeg since 1989, which in this business makes it something close to a founding elder. It is an Italian neighborhood place built on sharing plates and pasta, and it still lands on OpenTable's Diners' Choice list and in the local seasonal guides. Translation: the regulars never left.

Longevity like that is not luck. It usually means a kitchen that cooks the same good things the same good way, night after night, with no press release about it. I could not get hold of a current menu, so I will not pretend to recite one. The format tells you enough. Share a few plates, then commit to a pasta. That is how families eat when nobody is photographing the food, and it beats ordering a lonely entree and guarding it with your elbows.

Go on a weeknight with two or three people who like to pass dishes around. Ask the server what the kitchen has been making the longest, because a place that has outlasted more than three decades of food fads has a few dishes it would defend with its life. Book ahead on weekends. Then settle in and enjoy a room that never bothered chasing trends and is still here anyway.

Order this
Sharing plates for the table, A house pasta, Whatever the server says the kitchen has made the longest
The damage
$$
Go
A weeknight with two or three people who like to share
Find it
243 Lilac Street, Winnipeg