Toronto

Reviews Toronto Dinner

Bar Isabel, Little Italy
Bar Isabel, Little Italy

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Spanish restaurant in Little Italy, Toronto

Bar Isabel

Octopus on College Street

4 of 5

Bar Isabel opened in March 2013, and a good part of Toronto has been trying to copy it since. Grant van Gameren took his travels through Spain, Italy and France and built them into a small room on College Street with curved ceilings, hand-poured encaustic tiles, glass mosaics, a cherrywood bar and furniture that does not match on purpose. It looks like a tavern that has stood there for a century. It has not. That is craft.

The order is the octopus. Everyone says so, and for once everyone is right: grilled whole, smoky and tender, the dish the house built its name on. Around it, the kitchen under Megan Gnurlandino plays with Spanish and Basque ideas, from sobrasada with foie gras to roasted bone marrow to pinchos and small plates that start friendly arguments over the last bite. Finish with the gâteau basque. The wine list leans Spanish and Portuguese and rewards anyone willing to point at a bottle they cannot pronounce. I do that professionally.

It is fine dining dressed up as a neighbourhood bar, which is the best disguise a restaurant can wear. Alessandro Pietropaolo has run the floor since 2015, and that kind of continuity shows in how the room moves on a packed night. Book for dinner, or turn up late and stand at the bar with a glass of sherry. On a stretch of College where restaurants come and go like streetcars, this one stays.

Order this
Grilled octopus, Sobrasada with foie gras, Bone marrow, Gâteau basque
The damage
$$$
Go
Dinner, or late at the bar with a sherry
Find it
797 College St, Toronto, ON M6G 1C7