Edinburgh

Reviews Edinburgh Dinner

The Witchery by the Castle, Old Town (Castlehill)
The Witchery, Castlehill

Illustration by Fig & Ginger, drawn from the review. The venue's own photo is on its way.

Historic candlelit restaurant with suites in Old Town (Castlehill), Edinburgh

The Witchery by the Castle

Candlelight at the Castle Gates

3.5 of 5

Everything about The Witchery is too much, and that is the point. It sits in a merchant's house built in 1595 at the gates of Edinburgh Castle, at the top of the Royal Mile. James Thomson opened it in 1979 and it is now in its fifth decade. The name comes from the hundreds of people burned as witches on Castlehill in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Cheerful.

Walk down the close and into the Original Dining Room. Oak panelling rescued from a fire at St Giles' Cathedral. Painted, gilded ceilings modelled on Holyrood. Red leather, old hangings on the walls, church candlesticks everywhere. It is theatre, and it knows it. The menu leans into the same grand old manner. Tournedos Rossini. Omelette Arnold Bennett. Lobster thermidor from Eyemouth with triple-cooked chips. The house beef tartare, a fixture for years, comes with a St Ewe's egg yolk and, if you are feeling flush, caviar. There is haggis too, from Findlays of Portobello, with pineapple chutney and a potato bhaji, which is the most Edinburgh sentence on the menu.

You do not come here for the cutting edge. You come because it is the most dramatic room in the city and the wine list is the stuff of legend. The a la carte runs all day, and the set lunch is the sensible way in. Parties are capped at six and children under ten are not admitted, so plan accordingly.

Order this
Aged Scotch beef tartare with St Ewe's egg yolk, Grilled Eyemouth lobster thermidor with triple-cooked chips, Cumbrae rock oysters with mignonette, Findlays of Portobello haggis with pineapple chutney and potato bhaji
The damage
$$$$
Go
Late dinner, when the candles do the most work; the set lunch costs far less
Find it
352 Castlehill, The Royal Mile, Edinburgh EH1 2NF